Will This Tube Laser Meet Your Shift Target?
Before you buy a tube laser cutting machine, ask the supplier to run a representative shift’s worth of your orders using the quoted equipment and the crew you plan to assign. The machine meets the target for that run if it delivers the required quantity of every part, within your available production time, ready for the next operation.
A single-part cycle time can help you build a shortlist. The ranking can change once you account for replenishing the tube supply, changing profiles, checking first pieces, and unloading and sorting finished parts.

Define What You Need By The End Of The Shift
Start with a real shift from your production schedule. Write down how many minutes the machine can run, how many good parts you need for each part number, and how those parts must be handed over. If the next operation needs separate bins for each order, count a part toward the target once it has passed inspection and reached the right bin.
Choose a workload that reflects what you’re buying the machine to do. For long production runs, use a batch large enough to require replenishing the tube supply and clearing finished parts from the unload area. If you usually run smaller batches across several tube sizes, keep the batch sizes and changeovers in the trial. If both workloads matter to the purchase, compare them separately.
Give Each Supplier The Same Work
Send both suppliers the same drawings, tube specifications and stock lengths, quantities, inspection criteria, and sorting instructions. Keep any sequence required by delivery deadlines. For the remaining jobs, let suppliers choose their own sequence and record it. That gives each machine room to work efficiently while keeping the order requirements comparable.
Run each machine with the loading and unloading equipment in its quote and the number of people you expect to assign. If a supplier brings in an extra operator or uses optional equipment, ask for a revised quote that includes it or a rerun with the original setup. That gives you a result you can tie to a purchase decision.
Agree on the starting point before anyone runs the trial. For example, start with the tubes staged in the agreed area and loading yet to begin. Record elapsed time through inspection and sorting, including waits for material, changeovers, and first-piece approval. If an operator sorts parts while the machine cuts, record those activities on the same timeline so the overlapping time is counted once. If programming or inspection happens outside the timed window, note who does it and whether your shop can provide that support routinely.
Look At Which Orders Are Complete
Hypothetical example. You have 450 production minutes to deliver 240 good pieces of Part A and 160 of Part B, sorted into separate bins.
| Measure | Machine 1 | Machine 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Cutting time for the same batch of Part A | 42 minutes | 48 minutes |
| Good pieces of Part A handed over by shift end | 228 | 240 |
| Good pieces of Part B handed over by shift end | 172 | 160 |
| Result | 12 pieces short on Part A | Both orders complete at minute 438 |
Both machines deliver 400 good parts. Machine 1 cuts the comparison batch faster, but its surplus of Part B leaves the Part A order short. If the trial log shows that waiting for first-piece approval caused the shortfall, ask the supplier to repeat the run with an approval process your shop can actually staff. Machine 2 has enough evidence to move forward for this workload. Its 12 minutes of spare time are specific to this run.
Decide Whether To Shortlist, Retest, Or Approve
Use a single-part demo to decide whether a machine merits a mixed-order trial. If a short trial meets the target but leaves out a recurring task, test that task before relying on the estimate. For example, if the loader started full and never needed replenishing, measure what happens when the operator has to bring in the next bundle. If several changeovers could determine whether you meet the target, run the full representative shift.
When the machine completes that shift with the quoted setup and the staffing you can provide, use the order list, elapsed-time record, and good-part counts to support your approval decision. If it misses a required quantity, use the time log to identify what would need to change. Retest with a setup you can sustain, or take the current configuration off your shortlist.
To get started, send each supplier one trial sheet with your available production minutes, minimum good-part count by part number, and handoff requirements. Ask them to return it with the equipment used, crew size, timestamps, and actual counts for each order. Have them mark any estimates and state what they’re based on so you can see what still needs a trial.
